What are KPIs? Stop Drowning in Data, Start Making Decisions

"We track 147 different metrics," the CEO proudly announced. When I asked which three mattered most, he couldn't answer. Two quarters later, the company missed every important target while celebrating vanity metrics.

This is the KPI paradox: More data, worse decisions.

KPIs: Your Business GPS

Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) are measurable values that show if you're achieving critical business objectives.

Think of them as your business vital signs:

Heart rate = Revenue growth
Blood pressure = Cash flow
Temperature = Customer satisfaction
Oxygen level = Employee engagement

Track the wrong vitals, make the wrong diagnosis, prescribe the wrong cure.

The 5-7-15 Rule

After analyzing hundreds of companies, here's what works:

5 Company KPIs: What the CEO watches daily 7 Department KPIs: What each director owns 15 Individual KPIs: Maximum per employee

Total: ~50 KPIs for the entire company. Not 147. Not 500. Around 50.

North Star Metrics by Business Model

Every business needs one North Star—the single metric that best captures core value:

SaaS: Monthly Recurring Revenue (MRR) E-commerce: Gross Merchandise Value (GMV) Marketplace: Gross Transaction Value (GTV) Media: Daily Active Users (DAU) Subscription Box: Subscriber Retention Rate Agency: Revenue per Employee Manufacturing: Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE)

Your North Star aligns everyone. Everything else supports it.

The KPI Hierarchy That Works

Level 1: Company KPIs (The Big 5)

Revenue Growth (or MRR/ARR for SaaS)
Gross Margin (or Unit Economics)
Cash Flow (or Burn Rate if pre-profit)
Customer Satisfaction (NPS or Retention)
Team Health (Engagement or Turnover)

Level 2: Department KPIs

Sales:

Pipeline velocity
Win rate
Average deal size
Sales cycle length
Quota attainment

Marketing:

CAC by channel
Lead quality score
Marketing ROI
Brand awareness
Content engagement

Operations:

On-time delivery
Cost per unit
Inventory turnover
Quality score
Capacity utilization

Customer Success:

Churn rate
Expansion revenue
Support ticket resolution
Time to value
Health score

Level 3: Individual KPIs

Specific to role, tied to department KPIs, updated weekly.

Leading vs Lagging: The Fortune Teller's Secret

Lagging indicators tell you what happened:

Revenue (last month)
Churn (customers who left)
Profit (end of quarter)

Leading indicators predict what will happen:

Pipeline (future revenue)
Engagement score (future churn)
Operating margin trend (future profit)

Rule: 70% leading, 30% lagging. Most companies do the opposite.

Real KPIs vs Vanity Metrics

Vanity Metrics (Feel Good, Mean Nothing)

Total registered users (vs active users)
Revenue (vs profitable revenue)
Website traffic (vs conversions)
Social media followers (vs engagement)
Gross sales (vs net margin)

Real KPIs (Sometimes Painful, Always Useful)

Weekly active users
Contribution margin
Conversion rate
Engagement rate
Net revenue retention

Test: If the metric going up doesn't directly improve the business, it's vanity.

The Amazon KPI Evolution

Watch how their KPIs evolved with strategy:

1995-2000: Growth Phase

Unique visitors
Conversion rate
Repeat purchase rate

2000-2010: Scale Phase

Fulfillment cost per unit
Inventory turns
Prime member growth

2010-2020: Domination Phase

Same-day delivery percentage
AWS revenue growth
Advertising revenue

2020+: Optimization Phase

Carbon footprint per package
Employee safety score
Automation percentage

Lesson: KPIs must evolve or they become irrelevant.

Your KPI Selection Framework

For each potential KPI, ask:

Is it SMART?
- Specific (not vague)
- Measurable (has a number)
- Achievable (possible to hit)
- Relevant (matters to success)
- Time-bound (has a deadline)
Does it drive behavior?
- Clear action if it's red
- Celebration if it's green
- Someone owns it
Is it simple?
- Explained in one sentence
- Calculated without a PhD
- Updated automatically

If any answer is no, it's not a KPI.

Common KPI Mistakes

Mistake 1: The Kitchen Sink

Tracking everything because you can. Result: Analysis paralysis.

Mistake 2: Set and Forget

Creating KPIs then never reviewing. Result: Driving using the rearview mirror.

Mistake 3: No Owner

"We all own customer satisfaction." Result: No one owns it.

Mistake 4: Gaming the System

Sales hits target by giving massive discounts. Result: Margin destruction.

Mistake 5: One-Size-Fits-All

Using same KPIs for startup and enterprise. Result: Wrong medicine.

Building Your KPI Dashboard

Daily Dashboard (5 metrics max)

Cash position
Sales pipeline
Critical operational metric
Customer health indicator
Team capacity

Weekly Review (Department KPIs)

Trend analysis
Red/yellow/green status
Owner updates
Corrective actions

Monthly Strategic (All KPIs)

Full review
Correlation analysis
KPI effectiveness
Adjustments needed

Tools That Work

Simple: Google Sheets + Zapier
Growing: Databox, Geckoboard, Klipfolio
Advanced: Tableau, Looker, PowerBI

The OKR Connection

KPIs measure ongoing health. OKRs drive specific improvements.

Example:

KPI: Customer churn rate (always tracked)
OKR: Reduce churn from 5% to 3% in Q3 (specific initiative)

Think of KPIs as your speedometer (always there) and OKRs as your destination (specific journey).

Your 30-Day KPI Transformation

Week 1: Audit

List all current metrics
Identify who uses what
Find redundancies
Spot gaps

Week 2: Design

Select 5 company KPIs
Define department KPIs
Assign owners
Set targets

Week 3: Build

Create dashboards
Automate data feeds
Train teams
Test accuracy

Week 4: Launch

Daily standup integration
Weekly review rhythm
Monthly strategic review
Quarterly KPI assessment

The Ultimate KPI Test

Ask your team right now: "What are our top 5 KPIs and how are we doing?"

If they can't answer immediately, your KPIs aren't working.

Great KPIs become part of daily language:

"What's our NPS this week?"
"How's pipeline looking?"
"Where's burn rate at?"

When KPIs enter casual conversation, you've won.

Your Next Move

Stop tracking everything. Start tracking what matters.

This week:

List your current top 5 metrics
Ask: "If I could only know 5 things about my business, what would they be?"
Compare the lists
Fix the gap

Remember: The goal isn't perfect KPIs. It's better decisions. Start simple, iterate quickly, and let KPIs guide you to growth.

Want to implement KPIs effectively? Learn about OKRs for goal-setting, or dive into Business Intelligence for advanced analytics.

Part of the [Business Terms Collection]. Last updated: 2025-07-21

Business Terms